3D Printing
News Videos Newsletter Contact us
Home / 3D Printing Metal / When to choose Metal Injection Molding and when 3D Printing
qidi

When to choose Metal Injection Molding and when 3D Printing

October 6, 2020

Metal Injection Molding (MIM) has been around for some time, but has been plagued with issues including void formation and part fatigue problems. As will most things manufacturing, it has been enjoying a period of increased productivity lately due to improvements in the field.

But as with most processes that require designing and manufacturing a mold, it requires a large capex to get started… although once that initial chunk of money has been dropped on the table, the cost-per-part drops significantly.

But at which point does that price drop? When is a good time to use MIM compared to metal AM technologies. And can metal AM even match MIM in terms of the part quality?

MIM

LA-based steel printing company 3DEO has just published a white paper asking those exact questions, and has answered them in the context of their own steel printing service.

As a quick reminder, 3DEO uses their patented metal binding/sintering system for producing steel parts for a variety of industries including medical, automotive and aerospace and they offer a variety of finishes for their components. You can read more about their finishes in our previous article on surface finishing for metal AM parts.

And as a quick primer on what MIM is, you can take a peek at this lovely wikipedia graphic, explaining the process.

As you can tell from the graphic, the process is similar to granular printing / plastic injection molding in the sense that it uses a screw extruder to transport the granules (with binder)and heat them into a liquid state ready for injecting into the mold cavity under pressure. That is where the plastic injection molding comparison ends. Once the fluid hits the mold, it cools and unlike plastics, it is then taken from the mold, cleaned of debinder with some solvent, put into a thermal debinding stage, before being sent for final sintering. It is during the last stage where the metal grains are actually sintered together creating a dense part.

Metal AM

According to the aforementioned white paper, there is more value for MIM for production runs over 20,000 – 30,000 parts per year. And conversely, a binder/sinter metal AM system may be better for parts under 20k – 30k pieces.

So while it’s pretty clear that under 20k parts would be better served with metal AM, and over 30k parts with MIM, there is a bit of a grey area actually between 20k and 30k. No doubt projects falling into this range would need to be assessed in more depth between company and client.

Users in that grey may wish to consider the benefits of AM compared to MIM at this point. While the cost per part for certain items in the 20k-30k range will be similar at this price point, there are other values that you get beyond a simple reduction of cost per part.

MIM versus AM

For example, MIM parts are restricted in their geometry. The must have draft angles, overhangs and other features are costly to add and often require the addition of cams and sliders into the mold (expensive) to get these features which incur zero extra cost (asides from machine time etc) when AM is used.

Also consider the recurring mold costs which one must pay every time a design change occurs (or when the mold life expires).. 3DEO therefore recommends that for manufacturers who undergo many part iterations in production, they may wash to opt for metal AM. Those with a fairly rigid process and whose products remain the same, may prefer to go with the MIM for larger quantities. In this case MIM is preferred for those whose design will not change for 5-10 years.

So that is a summary of when you may wish to consider a binder/sinter type process for your larger production runs. Clearly at huge numbers 100k+, AM is still going to struggle to compete with MIM (and general plastic IM). But for those of you who want to iterate on the fly, maybe even change a design mid-production, if you’re looking at building under 30k parts, you may wish to consider some form of serial metal AM.

Download Guide
Related Story
Case Study: Exco Engineering Uses Metal AM For Automotive Die Cast Tooling
Share:
WhatsApp Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Buffer Reddit E-mail
About the author | Phillip Keane
Phillip is an aerospace engineer from UK. He is a graduate of Coventry University (UK), International Space University (France) and Nanyang Technological University (Singapore), where he studied Advanced Manufacturing at the Singapore Centre for 3D Printing.
Join our newsletter

Our newsletter is free & you can unsubscribe any time.

Latest posts

Fraunhofer, MacLean-Fogg, and Toyota Develop Large-Scale 3D Printing System for Automotive Die Casting Molds

The Fraunhofer Institute for Laser Technology ILT has partnered with powder manufacturer MacLean-Fogg and Toyota to develop a 3D printing solution for manufacturing... read more »

3D Printing Metal
Fraunhofer, MacLean-Fogg, and Toyota Develop Large-Scale 3D Printing System for Automotive Die Casting Molds

ASTM International Approves New Standard to Streamline AM Processes

ASTM International's additive manufacturing technologies committee (F42) has approved a new standard designed to help businesses navigate the procurement and delivery of 3D... read more »

News
ASTM International Approves New Standard to Streamline AM Processes

Trek Launches 3D Printed AirLoom Saddle Line

Trek has introduced its first 3D-printed saddle series, the Aeolus AirLoom, featuring what the company calls AirLoom lattice technology. The new design updates... read more »

News
Trek Launches 3D Printed AirLoom Saddle Line

QuesTek Partners with Niobium Producer to Develop High-Temperature 3D Printing Alloy

QuesTek Innovations has partnered with a global niobium producer to develop a high-temperature alloy designed for additive manufacturing. The project targets aerospace and... read more »

3D Printing Metal
QuesTek Partners with Niobium Producer to Develop High-Temperature 3D Printing Alloy

Autodesk Research and Additive Tectonics Develop 3D Printed Floor System with Alternative Materials

Autodesk Research has partnered with Additive Tectonics to develop a new approach to concrete floor construction using 3D printing technology. The collaboration combines... read more »

Construction

NREL Acquires Large-Scale Metal 3D Printer to Advance Marine Energy Research

The National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) has installed a new laser-powered metal 3D printer at its Flatirons Campus to support marine energy device... read more »

3D Printing Metal
NREL Acquires Large-Scale Metal 3D Printer to Advance Marine Energy Research

Apple Adopts 3D Printing for Titanium USB-C Ports in New iPhone Air

Apple’s latest smartphone release marks a quiet but notable step in consumer electronics manufacturing: the company has confirmed that its new iPhone Air... read more »

3D Printing Metal
Apple Iphone 17 air

GKN Aerospace Expands Connecticut Facility for 3D Printed Engine Components

GKN Aerospace announced the expansion of its Newington, Connecticut facility to include a new production line for additively manufactured Fan Case Mount Ring... read more »

Aerospace
GKN Aerospace Expands Connecticut Facility for 3D Printed Engine Components

UltiMaker Launches Secure 3D Printing Line for Defense Applications

UltiMaker has introduced its Secure Line of 3D printing products specifically designed for defense and high-security environments. The initial lineup includes the UltiMaker... read more »

News
UltiMaker Launches Secure 3D Printing Line for Defense Applications

Digital Manufacturing Centre Delivers 90kg 3D Printed Military Vehicle Component

The Digital Manufacturing Centre (DMC) has completed production of its largest additive manufacturing metal component to date - a 90kg suspension and differential... read more »

3D Printing Metal
Digital Manufacturing Centre Delivers 90kg 3D Printed Military Vehicle Component

Social

  • Facebook Facebook 3D Printing
  • Linkedin Linkedin 3D Printing
Join our newsletter

Our newsletter is free & you can unsubscribe any time.

Featured Industries

  • Automotive
  • Aerospace
  • Construction
  • Dental
  • Environmental
  • Electronics
  • Fashion
  • Medical
  • Military
  • Snapmaker Artisan Premium 3-in-1

    • - Print size: 400 x 400 x 400 mm
    • - comes with enclosure
    More details »
    $2,999.00 Snapmaker
    Buy Now
  • QIDI Tech X-Max 3

    • - Print size: 325 x 325 x 315 mm
    • - fully enclosed
    More details »
    $799.00 QIDI Store
    Buy Now
  • QIDI Tech Q1 Pro

    • - Print size: 245 x 245 x 245 mm
    • - 600mm/s max speed
    More details »
    $449.00 QIDI Store
    Buy Now
  • QIDI Plus4

    • - Print size: 305 x 305 x 280 mm
    • - print temperature of 370°C
    More details »
    $799.00 QIDI Store
    Buy Now

Company Information

  • What is 3D Printing?
  • Contact us
  • Join our mailing list
  • Advertise with us
  • Media Kit
  • Nederland 3D Printing

Blog

  • Latest News
  • Use Cases
  • Reviews
  • 3D Printers
  • 3D Printing Metal

Featured Reviews

  • Anycubic Photon Mono M5s
  • Creality Ender 5 S1
  • The Mole 3D Scanner
  • Flashforge Creator 3 Pro

Featured Industries

  • Automotive
  • Aerospace
  • Construction
  • Dental
  • Environmental
  • Electronics
  • Medical
  • Military
  • Fashion
  • Art
2025 — Strikwerda en Dehue
  • Home
  • Join our mailing list
  • Contact us
Blog
  • Latest News
  • Use Cases
  • Reviews
  • 3D Printers
  • 3D Printing Metal
Featured Industries
  • Automotive
  • Aerospace
  • Construction
  • Dental
  • Environmental
  • Electronics
  • Medical
  • Military
  • Fashion
  • Art
Company Information
  • What is 3D Printing?
  • Contact us
  • Join our mailing list
  • Advertise with us
  • Media Kit
  • Nederland 3D Printing